[SPR-1142] Load files in <import resource=.../> only once Created: 15/Jul/05 Updated: 15/Jan/19
|Fix Version/s:||Waiting for Triage|
|Reporter:||Martin Zeltner||Assignee:||Juergen Hoeller|
|Remaining Estimate:||Not Specified|
|Time Spent:||Not Specified|
|Original Estimate:||Not Specified|
|Days since last comment:||22 weeks, 1 day ago|
|Last commented by a User:||true|
If I load now an application context which has "file1.xml" and "file2.xml" as config locations, the file "common-config.xml" will be loaded twice. I suggest to remember the url of already loaded config files.
|Comment by Sébastien Launay [ 05/Jan/10 ]|
Because this issue is opened for many years I was thinking of proposing a solution because our spring configuration uses lots of XML files decomposed with imports and lots of AOP configuration and computing unused bean definitions is expensive at runtime.
So here is a patch for loading application context resources only once against the trunk.
This feature is enabled by setting the bean property importOnce to true on *XmlApplicationContext.
I do not know if this is interesting but I do not modified JavaConfig classes to reflect such behavior with @Import.
Let me know if this approach is right or if I need to go in another direction.
|Comment by Tim Ducheyne [ 12/Aug/10 ]|
Just a small remark about the patch:
There is a problem with the hashcode and equals implementation of URL
|Comment by Felix Simmendinger [ 30/Sep/10 ]|
This behaviour is espacially then problematic, because BPP are executed multiple times if they are declared as anonymous beans or defined via a namespace eg. <context:property-placeholder ... . For the latter it is impossible to define an id. Since there are special beans that can be defined only once eg. the multipartresolver this problem means you cannot hide the multipartresolver in a xml file hierarchy as it may be loaded twice.
|Comment by Dennis Homann [ 17/Feb/11 ]|
This is a real pain and punishes people who modularize their application context in multiple smaller XML files.
|Comment by Keith Donald [ 19/Feb/11 ]|
Can someone provide more info on why you would import the same file more than once? I'm curious what is trying to be accomplished where this comes up, as I've never encountered this myself in practice.
|Comment by Dale Wyttenbach [ 19/Feb/11 ]|
It typically happens indirectly:
|Comment by Andy Schäfer [ 26/Mar/11 ]|
Some additional thoughts to the comment of Dale Wyttenbach in answer to Keith Donald:
In order to ensure, that C isn't loaded twice we import in the topmost application.spring.xml all configurations (A, B, C and D). So the import of C is done only there, nowhere else.
1) Design-flaw: dependencies between configurations aren't expressed explicitly
2) Running Tests: In order to run tests concerning for example B we had to load the configuration of B and C. Assumed C gets a dependency to a new configuration-file E, ALL tests of A,B,C AND D had to be changed. Instead we load the complete application-context for our tests. But now D and A are unnecessarily loaded for our B-test -> turnaround time increases.
Maybe there are approaches better than the one I outlined (interested to hear of them), but this issue would be handy to solve the problem in a simple way:
1) dependencies can be expressed explicitly (e.g. B imports C)
|Comment by Neha [ 04/Mar/14 ]|
Since this issue had been logged around 9 years back and is still unresolved, I was just wondering if there is some major reason for it?
|Comment by Lucian Yao [ 10/Jun/15 ]|
Please fix this issue. I was blamed by the peers by using the import in lower-level modules to save a lot of time in config and deploy.
|Comment by Spring Issuemaster [ 14/Jan/19 ]|